Find an event

Radio’s worst week ever

Posted in Robert Feder | Chicago Media blog by Robert Feder on Oct 28, 2011 at 12:00am

A lot of good people lost their jobs at radio stations all over the country this week.

In most cases, it didn’t matter whether they were talented and capable or whether their stations were successful and profitable. They were fired because the huge companies they worked for didn’t want to pay their salaries anymore.

Dozens of program directors were among those who suddenly found themselves unemployed and unlikely to find new jobs commensurate with their skills and experience. I know two of them personally, and consider both to have been among the best in the business.

Michael LaCrosse, who until Tuesday was operations director of oldies WLS-FM (94.7), told me that he considered himself “really lucky” to have worked at a couple of great stations in his home town — even if his layoff by Cumulus Media means the end of his career here. “Most people aren’t that fortunate,” he said without bitterness.

Mark Edwards, another old friend from his days as vice president of programming at adult contemporary WLIT-FM (93.9), was forced out in a “cost restructuring” Thursday as program director of Entercom Communications’ KZPT-FM in Kansas City. “Everyone says it was not performance,” he told me. “I was just the only PD in the building not holding down an air shift or programming more than one station.”

Clear Channel Radio won’t say how many employees it laid off in small and medium markets Wednesday, but industry websites estimated they were in the hundreds. One of the sites, Joel Denver’s AllAccess.com, carried running tallies of the victims’ names as waves of firings were carried out from coast to coast.

Even Inside Radio, the daily newsletter wholly owned by Clear Channel, couldn’t sugarcoat the facts: “The downsizing appears to be [Clear Channel’s] largest since it reduced the workforce by a combined 11 percent in 2009,” the publication reported Thursday. “The new dismissals hit program directors, assistant program directors, music directors, producers and air talent, including ones that were voicetracking shows for other stations. Some were even the top talent in their timeslot on a top-ranked station.”

Unlike the layoffs at Cumulus and Entercom, Clear Channel insisted that its actions this week were not about cutting costs. “We’re making these changes to improve the quality of what we provide to each of our local communities,” a company spokesperson told Inside Radio. “There will be more localization, not less.” Imagine that.

Amid the carnage, some inspiring stories of integrity emerged. John Laton, an 11-year veteran of Clear Channel who most recently had been vice president/market manager for the Quad Cities, Cedar Rapids and Iowa City, quit rather than implement firings he believed to be undeserved and counterproductive. “I just said, ‘Enough already,’ ” Laton told Duane Dudek of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.

Within days, Laton was snatched up as Milwaukee market manager for Spanish-language Adelante Media Group. “I actually get to go to work every day and use my best judgment,” Laton said of his new job. “My input will not only be respected, but as importantly, expected in this company’s culture. For the first time in a very long time, I will be in control of my own destiny.”

Previous post
Next post
10/28/2011
Share with your network
Comment
Comments
Seems like just another week in the United Corporations of America, to me. Oh, who knows? Maybe stations will be sold back to local owners? Hah! I crack me up!
By Prof Zed (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 12:07 am
Why? Greed and borrowing huge piles of money to leverage their media ownership. Hello Sam Zell. One of the biggest financiers when Bush & Cronies deregulated was... Bear Stearns. What happened to them? Got sold to JP Morgan Chase for $10 per share, a price far below the pre-crisis 52-week high of $133.20 per share. No soap, radio.
By Marc Coney (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 12:29 am
i'm not sure why these middle-manager hacks have been around this long. every station plays there own 300-song shuffle. every city has the same 5 variations on pop/rock subgenres. the few true talents complained about these glorified salesman dictating them to tone it down. more time and temp followed by more temp and time, and the big event happening at 7:20 am. bye bye buggy-whips.
By squatch (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 12:45 am
Really?? An automated Herb Kent? DAG!
By Rufus (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 12:54 am
Blame the Telecom Act of 1996-- it turned all of radio into one giant oligopoly--which, in turn, extinguished the creativity and talent once found in markets like Chicago and Boston. If radio companies like CC won't provide local programming/talent, then why should anyone listen to terrestrial radio? Satellite & Wi-Fi offer much better sound quality--without commercials. These new services may not be local, but neither is terrestrial radio anymore--so who cares? I am a former program director now living in the NYC metro, and my car radio has 18 preset buttons for terrestrial radio. After living here for over 5 years, I have only managed to set 1 of those buttons--to the NPR affiliate....otherwise I listen to Sirius/XM, or my MP3 player. Radio as we've known it.....is dead.
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 3:07 am
I saw the headline above, and all I could hear was "The Simpson's" Comic Book Guy saying that phrase. Obviously not so funny for the people who toiled and labored so hard, getting a pink slip as their reward....
By Bob Y. (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 3:26 am
ok who owns the company that owns wilv 100.3?
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 6:30 am
If only a really talented radio personality would start a subscription based service that would be the wave of the future. Radio on demand.
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 7:06 am
...and to think I just donated to WDCB in suburban Chicago, no firings their as long as we keep the station going with our gifts...but the real gift is theirs to us, great Jazz music and programming!!!
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 7:35 am
clear channel is a discrace...i hope there rating plummet...they will keep the fat cats rich...shame on u clear channel..u will hurt yourself just like netflix...
By jack (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 8:41 am
They've realized that the license, not the programming, is the asset. They make about the same amount of money no matter what they put on, so why bother to spend money on people who might make the product better?
By DeJordy (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 8:48 am
Could we please conduct an online course on how to use the words "their" and "there". Good Lord!
By Robert (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 8:50 am
ChickaBOOMer: Radio Daze http://chickaboomer.blogspot.com/2011/10/radio-daze.html
By StewartIII (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 9:43 am
I'm not sure if this is all really a surprise to any really astute observer watching the radio industry over the last several years. It's the perfect storm really. A 3 year recession occurring at a time when just about everyone in this country has a mobile device to shuffle their own 1000 tune Steve Jobs playlist of music. Do we really need some local yokel to give us the time, temp, silly quip about last night's X FACTOR? (All that stuff is also available ON DEMAND on my iPhone by the way!) Of course this is just the last ditch effort by Clear Channel to milk as much money out of their lame programming before they turn on the "off" switch on their whole messed up operation. (There's a reason Steve Jobs didn't believe in "off" switches!)
By What Did You Think Was Going To Happen (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 10:02 am
Robert, I'm with you on there, their, they're! Jeepers! Also, don't people proof read their comments before posting them? What am I missing?
By WTSL (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 10:06 am
Maybe it would help to explain what a radio programming or operations director actually does. For instance, WLIT's programming hasn't changed in decades, and if the only question is the date on which to go "all Christmas all the time," it doesn't need a full time staffer to decide that (although rereading apparently he was forced out in KC, not here). But, perhaps you could elucidate.
By jack (the real one) (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 10:06 am
It's about time that people realize it's not about being the Best Broadcaster its all about being the Biggest Broadcaster. Unfortunately the Mini Market Morons who have pasted together these "Giants" can neither serve their communities correctly as Broadcasters nor can they take care of their own employees as business owners....Way to go you just turned off the music.....
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 10:16 am
This has little to do with radio and everything to do with a corporation which put itself $18 billion in debt with no chance of ever getting out, even before the crash when cash was flooding the Clear Channel coffers. Who here thinks any single radio station was worth $300 million, ever? Do the debt service math...its insane. I feel sorry for everyone losing a job in this but you can't work on a leaky boat without getting wet.
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 10:23 am
You got it exactly right. It WAS insane. But, mostly thinking they could make easy money and didn't and not caring about the people who work there, or, more importantly, US, who listen on the public airwaves they "own" the licenses theirselves.
By Beany Counter (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 10:39 am
Cumulus Media, as in "the Cloud," envelops hundreds of more jobs. Actually, with all the stormy times these actions are producing, Cumulus Media should be called Cumulonimbus Media or Nimbostratus Media.
By weatherman (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 11:38 am
@Beany Counter: Precisely. And this should be a lesson for anyone working for Merlin Media today. The same corporate ethic is alive and well and in the driver's seat.
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 1:05 pm
@If only a really talented radio personality would start a subscription based service that would be the wave of the future. Radio on demand. By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 7:06 am Give it up Dahl, nobody will pay for your crap.
By Laughs at Dahl (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 2:28 pm
WTSL - "Proofread" is one word, and Robert - the period goes inside the quotation mark. (A question mark, which should have ended the sentence, goes outside the quotation mark.) They're you go . . .
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 3:27 pm
Clear Channel insisted that its actions this week were not about cutting costs. “We’re making these changes to improve the quality of what we provide to each of our local communities,” a company spokesperson told Inside Radio. The spokesman couldn't be bothered to make up something plausibly stupid, as opposed to this, which is insanely stupid.
By Shane Gericke (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 5:33 pm
Dahl may charge..but Fred Winston, Tommy Edwards, Mitch Michaels, Bill Garcia, Nancy Turner, Doug Dahlgren, Connie Szerszen, Clark Weber, Scotty Brink, and Linda Marshall don't... check out www.chicagoradioonline.com
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 5:55 pm
One of the best bits of writing that Rob Feder has ever done --- insightful, textured and with extremely commendable topspin. Very well done, Robert. Now please utilize the same prism to tell the truth about the ultra-embarrassing Handi-Wipe we formerly worked at. Shalom.
By Jim O'Donnell (really) (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 6:02 pm
Shouldn't it be quite a simple matter for locals in these various markets who are fed up with these remote conglomerates ruining the local airwaves to petition the FCC to revoke these stations' licenses? I mean, that's the way it's supposed to work, isn't it? The airwaves belong to the public, and these markets are local. Remote ownership should be out of the question if local listeners don't want it. So why does this farcical situation persist? For that matter, why does the FCC exist? Airwaves are local. Why should a panel in Washington determine what we have to listen to in Chicago -- or Kansas City or Cedar Rapids or wherever? It makes zero sense and we shouldn't tolerate it.
By Pelham (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 6:39 pm
No, the worst week was July 2000 when CBS pulled the plug on all the jobs at WMAQ-AM.
By you give us 22 minutes & we'll give all of you a pink slip (not verified) on 10/28/2011 at 9:34 pm
Anonymous at 3:27, what's with the hyphens (or are those dashes?)? Thar you go.
By Bruce Wolf (not verified) on 10/29/2011 at 6:30 am
@ Bruce, from Anonymous at 3:27 - The lack of em-dashes in this system is maddening, and I didn't want to over-colon. So there I was, like Strunk without White, trapped in Grammar/Punctuation Hell . . . flailing helplessly in th'air . .
By Anonymous (not verified) on 10/29/2011 at 10:03 am
JUST DISGUSTING WHAT HAPPENNED! What happenned to the "LIVE AND LOCAL" concept in radio. It seems like more and more we are forced to websites for info and forced to pay for info to find out what is happenning in our back yards. Is it possible that some owners will buy stations locally again and bring back the old ways of free radio? Speaking of change, I am really liking this online site (geez I had to adapt myself to internet radio): WWW.SLAMINTERNETRADIO.COM and ustream.com/slamir based in Chicago and talking local stuff, even though it is on the internet available anywhere!
By MARIO DEEJAYE (not verified) on 10/29/2011 at 2:23 pm
A superb column, Rob. One of your best, and not just for the insightful analysis, but the links to other sources for further information. I hope the event that inspires your next best-ever column will be happier. Or at least more optimistic. Keep up the great work.
By Dan Miller (not verified) on 10/30/2011 at 11:50 am
I can't imagine why anyone is surprised at all this? This isn;t just happening in radio as if station owners are the only eeeevil corporate monsters in the world. This is happening in EVERY industry. t's simply a result of living high off the hog for decades in a false high that WWII caused the US to enjoy. It never did make sense to pay an auto worker $40 an hour and all sort of bennies to put nut A on bolt B. It is the same in nearly every industry. Is this all fun? Does it cause glee? No. Is it inevitable? Sadly, I think it is.
By Warner Todd Huston (not verified) on 10/30/2011 at 3:45 pm
The difference between Entercom and Clear Channel is that Entercom does not fire PDs "just because they are not on the air". Entercom has several other stations with off-air PDs. You cannot compare the firing of hundreds of content-focused employees to the firing of one under-performing PD in one middle market.
By Anonymous (not verified) on 11/03/2011 at 2:02 pm
Have an Opinion? Let's hear it
About Robert Feder
Robert Feder has been keeping tabs on the media for more than three decades, including 28 years as a reporter and television/radio columnist for the Chicago Sun-Times. He's a lifelong Chicagoan and graduate of the Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern University. At age 14, he founded the first and only Walter Cronkite Fan Club.
Subscribe via e-mail

Browse the archives