Find a restaurant
Find an event
Connect to share what you're reading and see friend activity. (?)

Natural deodorants

We test-drive five natural deodorants.

By Kevin Aeh and Jessica Herman
Published: May 31, 2012

379.sh.ss.td.Deodorant
378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LavanilaxSS.jpg
378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LifeStinksxSS.jpg
378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LushxSS.jpg
378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.MalinGoetzxSS.jpg
378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.WeledaxSS.jpg
  • 378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LavanilaxSS.jpg

    Lavanila, $18 at lavanila.com

    Just for the ladies Cliché as it may be, there’s something about the powdery smell of Secret that makes me feel like a lady. The vanilla-lavender scent of Lavanila scratches that itch, and the mildly powdery deo moisturizes my pits. Unfortunately, when it came time for the real test–a butt-kicking gym class–I did detect my own less savory scent; I’m leaving this one for easy breezier days at the office.

    378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LavanilaxSS.jpg378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LavanilaxSS.jpg153935661
  • 378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LifeStinksxSS.jpg

    Lifestinks, $15 for regular-strength travel size at duggansisters.com

    She says: I’m not crazy about the application of this locally made product—sprinkle the powder in your hands and pat into your pits—particularly when I need to rush out the door. I like the mild scent (lavender or cedar), however, and feel confident that on sweatier days, the extra-strength powder option and tea-tree-and-lavender-oil-blend stinkstick (rolled on before powder application for extra-stanky days) have me covered for even the most anxiety-provoking presentation at work.

    He says: Not fond of the powder, either. In my morning routine, I apply deodorant then my face moisturizer. Having to wash my powdery hands in between slows me down. I test the cedar powder and it smells like…nothing. But I also remain scent-free for the rest of the day.

    378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LifeStinksxSS.jpg378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LifeStinksxSS.jpg153935712
  • 378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LushxSS.jpg

    The Guv’ner by LUSH, $10 at Lush (859 W Armitage Ave, 773-281-5874; 1727 N Damen Ave, 773-227-3946)

    Just for fellas This powdery deodorant contains charcoal, lavender and patchouli powders, which somehow manage to smell masculine. The application is annoying: I pour a small amount of the product onto a piece of toilet paper and then dab it under my arms. Stray grayish powder falls on the bathroom floor. But the scent is strong enough that I don’t have to wear cologne and the thick powder absorbs sweat, which is as close to an antiperspirant as I’m going to get here.

    378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LushxSS.jpg378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.LushxSS.jpg153935763
  • 378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.MalinGoetzxSS.jpg

    Malin + Goetz eucalyptus deodorant, $18 at Aaron’s Apothecary (2338 N Clark St, 773-360-8595)

    She says: The refreshing eucalyptus scent of Malin + Goetz’s best-selling product wins me over, but it’s actually so strong it competes with the perfume I spritz on my neck; in other words, it doubles as my outdoorsy perfume. On a particularly warm day, I end up needing to reapply about four hours in, but I like the smell and feel of the stick so much, I don’t even mind.

    He says: The eucalyptus scent is so refreshing, it smells like a fancy gym or spa. I like that the application of this one is the most traditional: You just roll it on. I don’t need to reapply throughout the day, but I do wish these natural deodorants had some natural antiperspirant properties in them. Can someone please invent that?

    378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.MalinGoetzxSS.jpg378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.MalinGoetzxSS.jpg153935814
  • 378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.WeledaxSS.jpg

    Weleda sage deodorant, $8 at Merz Apothecary (4716 N Lincoln Ave, 773-989-0900; 17 E Monroe St, 312-781-6900)

    She says: Full disclosure: I’m not a fan of spray-on deo, so Weleda has an immediate disadvantage. Not to mention, the sage fragrance is so initially potent it smells as if I’ve bathed in sage. Fortunately, the dry-down happens quickly and the residual scent is mildly earthy but not overpowering. I remain surprisingly body-odor-free for the day.

    He says: I don’t mind a spray bottle, and the strong sage scent doesn’t bother me at first. The spray creates a cooling, tingly sensation, which isn’t unpleasant, either. Midday, however, I get a whiff of sage mixed with sweat, and I have to reapply. I wish this product were able to last throughout the day.

    378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.WeledaxSS.jpg378.sh.ss.td.Deodorant.WeledaxSS.jpg153935865

Lavanila, $18 at lavanila.com

Just for the ladies Cliché as it may be, there’s something about the powdery smell of Secret that makes me feel like a lady. The vanilla-lavender scent of Lavanila scratches that itch, and the mildly powdery deo moisturizes my pits. Unfortunately, when it came time for the real test–a butt-kicking gym class–I did detect my own less savory scent; I’m leaving this one for easy breezier days at the office.

.

Share with your network
Comment